Stack A Butter Squishy Butter List, Prices and Rarities

Search by butter name or alias, then use the rarity filter to narrow the results. Open More details on an entry for its additional attributes and acquisition relationships. Reset clears the search, filters and sorting.

The directory includes 15 Common–Epic butters, six Legendary butters, seven Mythic butters, Divine Souffle Pancake Butter and Limited Keyboard Butter.

Keep these names separate when searching:

• Marshmellow Butter uses that spelling in the game.
• Cake Butter is Epic; Cake Pop Butter is a different, Rare collectible.
• Macaron Butter is an Epic squishy, separate from a base skin.
• Keyboard Butter also appears as ADMIN Keyboard in the Shop.

Common → Rare → Epic → Legendary → Mythic → Celestial → Divine

Keyboard Butter has a separate Limited label. Golden Glaze is a variant, rather than another step in this rarity order. Keep ordinary Cookie Butter’s values separate from Golden Cookie Butter; see Golden Glaze and Golden Touch for the variant’s mechanics.

Rarity helps organize your collection, but each butter’s own output matters when choosing an income upgrade:

• Common Peanut Butter lists $40 per squish, above Rare Blueberry Butter’s $25 per squish.
• Epic Muffin Butter and Legendary Dubai Butter both list $10,000 per squish. Moving up a rarity does not increase output in that comparison.

The Index uses $/squish, meaning cash per squish. Edit Stack uses $/s, meaning cash per second for that butter in your current setup. Compare values with the same unit and conditions; an individual Edit Stack reading is not a replacement for the butter’s Index value.

A butter’s Buy price is the cost of taking that named result. Its per-squish earnings are output, and a crate opening fee pays for a random reward. Cash abbreviations use k = thousand, M = million and B = billion. Prices marked Robux use a separate currency.

Use the current Buy prompt for your budget. Offers can differ: Chocolate Butter has $200 and $194 offers, for example. Frog’s ability makes butters 3% cheaper, but the current quote is what you need to afford.

For direct purchases, use Roll Squishy, inspect the result and buy the butter you want. Rolling again replaces the result, so collect pending stack cash before rerolling an expensive butter you intend to keep. If every Wax Station is busy, either wait for one to finish or include the station you intend to buy in your budget.

Keyboard Butter’s Get LIMITED Squishy offer is 2,000 Robux with Plus, with 2,499 Robux shown as the crossed-out price. Its purchase guide covers that separate route.

Crates and daily rewards

• Blueberry Butter: Snack Crate gives a 30% chance per opening. A paid opening costs $250; a separate FREE offer can also appear. At the crate, use Open to inspect the menu and its fee before opening.
• Grape Butter: Bakery Crate costs $125,000 per opening, with a 50% chance of Grape. Its reward preview displays $1.2k per squish, while the Index displays $1.3k per squish. Keep those display contexts separate.
• Cake Pop Butter: Claim it free when your Day 5 Daily Rewards slot offers Cake Pop and becomes available. Some reward panels instead offer Blossom Butter on Day 5. Rewards wait for you if you miss a day; use the item shown in your panel to plan your collection.

A direct Buy offer secures the named butter already in front of you. A crate can cost less to open, but it does not guarantee your target; the percentages above are crate chances, not lever-roll odds. Carry a crate reward to a Wax Station for processing. See crate costs and rewards for the other reward options, or Daily Rewards for the seven-day schedule.

1. Open Index → Butters. Scroll through the rarity groups and look for entries marked with ??? and a silhouette.
2. Acquire a type you still need through its direct Buy offer, crate route or available reward.
3. Carry the butter to an available Wax Station and use Place Squishy. The station begins pouring and displays a countdown.
4. Let processing finish so the butter can join your plate. Use the station’s current timer to judge the wait; processing times differ between butters and setups.
5. Return to Index → Butters to review your discoveries and choose the next missing type.

Keep a missing type long enough to process it. Buying a Cake Butter and selling it immediately can leave that collection goal unfinished; processing a later Cake Butter can produce New Butter! Cake Butter. If you decide to give up a held butter, use the selling guide.

Other stations continue processing while you buy or carry another squishy. Read the name in a New Butter! notification—it can belong to a butter finishing elsewhere, rather than the one in your hands.

Stack count and collection count

Multiple Cake Pop Butters can occupy separate positions and contribute income to the same stack. Those copies increase the number of individual butters, while Index progress counts different types.

The 20-type Index milestone awards 150 Guild XP. A stack can therefore contain 43 individual butters while reaching its twentieth discovered type. To advance the Index, prioritize a missing type over another copy of one you already have.

• Fill Legendary or Mythic gaps: Buy the named lever result you need, or pursue a crate that includes it. Gourmet Crate can award Gummy and Tanghulu; Royal Crate can award Icecream and Mochi. Use the Legendary and Mythic acquisition guide to compare those routes and their cash requirements.
• Improve income within a budget: Compare the purchase price and output together. Muffin’s $2M offer buys the same listed $10,000 per squish as Dubai’s $6.25M offer, making Muffin the more economical choice for that output if both are available. See best butters for money by budget for the wider comparison.
• Consider a scaling Limited butter: Keyboard’s advertised 500% of your best squishy means 5× that output, rather than a fixed cash amount. Its value grows with your best squishy; read the Keyboard Butter guide before choosing the Robux purchase.
• Collect a different form: A Golden Cookie is a variant of the cookie-themed butter. Follow Golden Glaze and Golden Touch for the appearance and chance-based effect.
• Choose for sound or interaction: Popcorn offers a crunchy squish sound, Keyboard has keyboard sounds, and Boba’s pearls move when pressed. Explore butter sounds and squish effects for more choices.

For a Divine lookup, Souffle Pancake Butter has an Index value of $625 million per squish.